🍽️ Best Restaurants in Old Lyme, CT

Discover 22 top-rated restaurants in Old Lyme, ranked by real visitor reviews. Watch video reviews and find your next favorite spot.

22 restaurants to explore

Explore Old Lyme on the Map

Top Restaurants in Old Lyme

Ranked by visitor ratings and reviews

1.

Pizza Plus

2.

Sapore Pizzeria & Bar

3.

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace

4.

Pizzaria Da Vinci

5.

The Hideaway Restaurant and Pub

6.

Chestnut Grille at the Bee & Thistle Inn

7.

Grandmas Market & Catering

Black Hall Grille

Papi's Taqueria

Joey's by Illiano's

Stella's Restaurant and Pizzeria

12.

A.C. Petersen

13.

Salty Monkey

14.

Hideaway Restaurant & Pub

15.

Subway

16.

Hong Kong II

17.

ZENSHI Handcrafted Sushi

18.

The Hideaway

19.

Illiano's Ristorante

20.

Kokomo's Restaurant & Beach Bar

21.

Surface Shack

22.

Old Lyme Seafood

More in Old Lyme

☕Cafes & Coffee 🍸Bars & Nightlife 🍔Fast Food 🍰Bakeries & Desserts 🏨Hotels & Motels ⛺Campgrounds & RV 🎡Attractions 🌳Parks & Nature 🏛️Museums 🖼️Art Galleries 🎢Amusement Parks ⛪Places of Worship 🏋️Gyms & Fitness 🏌️Golf Courses 🏬Malls & Centers 👗Clothing & Fashion

Plan Your Visit to Old Lyme

Use our AI trip planner to build the perfect itinerary for Old Lyme, CT.

Plan a Trip All Things to Do in Old Lyme